This week I saw two films that in many ways dealt with similar themes, but in different ways.
First up,
I Am Legend. As always, spoilers will probably be contained below.

The film is based on the novella by
Richard Matheson. In the film version, a scientist develops what appears to be a cure for cancer but ultimately kills nearly 90% of the world's population. Of the remaining survivors, most become vampire/zombie like creatures that then feed on the remaining "immune" population. Robert Neville, the only apparent survivor, is left to fend for himself while working to reverse the infection. Right about there is where the story stops making any kind of sense. Robert Neville, the military scientist that may be the only person on Earth that can reverse the infection is both somehow immune to the virus and able to survive the vampire apocalypse. That's pretty convenient, but as we will later find out, it was all according to "plan". Neville spends many years working on a cure only to discover it minutes before he is killed, but that's ok because "God" sent a couple of random people to take his cure to a protected settlement of survivors. Yep, that's right, the movie is ultimately about divine intervention. So, we see a world where science has gone wrong and nearly destroyed the human race. However, science also has the power to redeem man, but only after God takes care of some of the details. I found this to be very heavy handed and it comes in the last 20 minutes completely out of left field. I don't generally have a problem with religious messages even though I don't believe in such things, but the way it was handled in this film just didn't fit. It felt slapped on when the screenwriters couldn't figure out a way to end the film. Bad writing at best, pandering at worst.
Now, let's talk about the one thing I REALLY didn't get. Apparently there is at least one zombie/vampire that can think on a level a little higher than the others. He is smart enough to lure Neville into a trap and also seems to have some kind of control over the other zompires (eh, how do you like that word..."zompires"?). Why then, when it comes to the "climax" of the story does the brainy zompire resort to banging his head against a Plexiglas enclosure for ten minutes trying to get at Neville? Couldn't he get one of the other's to do it? Ok, how about this? Most of the human "food" has been gone for years by the time of the story. How are thousands and thousands of zompires feeding well enough to have six pack abs and new superhuman strength? Yes, I realize animals are running free in the streets of New York, but they would have exhausted that food supply long before the events of the film take place. Thirdly, can a virus be so mutative that it changes human cranial and mandibular structure and not be 100% fatal? This stuff just doesn't add up even in Hollywood fantasy land.
DC Comics fans will not the Superman/Batman billboard in Times Square. Is this a subtle hint of a movie to come? We can hope. Observant viewers will also see references to Green Lantern and Teen Titans. Cross promotion at its best eh? I didn't get the Shrek thing though. I thought that was a Dreamworks film. Wonder how Warner got the right to use that one. You know, that was really the best part of this film...looking at the background. Sad isn't it?
One more word on this movie and I am done. Why, why, why, did this film need computer generated zompires? Much better effects could have been done through traditional make-up with only the occasional CG effect needed to fill in the environment. The producers, however, decided that all CG monsters would be best and this was a bad idea. They look horrible and are completely unconvincing. Someone should really be ashamed.
The next film I saw this week was one I have been waiting on since early last year. Danny Boyle's
Sunshine.

I have been a Danny Boyle fan since
Trainspotting and one of my favorite films of recent years was
28 Days Later. I don't remember when I heard about this film but I know I was looking forward to it for most of 2007. It opened in very few theaters and I never had a chance to see it during its initial run. The film came out on DVD last week and I got it through Netflix on release day.
Sunshine is about a future where our Sun is dying. Solar winter has engulfed the Earth and the inhabitants of the planet have made a desperate attempt to re-ignite the Sun. The first mission, Icarus I, was sent to the sun with a nuclear payload designed to restart the Sun 's hydrogen fusion process. The Icarus I, however, was lost and Earth sent a second mission to the Sun. This is where our story starts. The Icarus II's mission is proceeding according to plan until Mercury passes through the ship's flight path. With Mercury blocking some of the Sun's interference, Icarus II detects Icarus I's distress beacon. A choice is made to intercept Icarus I and add its payload to Icarus's II payload thus increasing the chances of re-ignition success. This choice, of course, proves fatal and the crew end up struggling to stay alive and complete their mission.
This film become the antithesis of I Am Legend. The captain of the Icarus I somehow manages to survive the 7 years it took Icarus II to reach Icarus I. Most of his body is burned from prolonged exposure to the Sun and he is completely insane. Captain Pinbacker has become convinced God has chosen him to be the last man alive. He feels it is his duty to see "God's Work" done and the Earth destroyed. It is for this reason he tries to sabotage Icarus II. Here, however, the fanatic loses and science wins out.
Again here is a film that goes completely weird in the last reel. Pinkbacker surviving his unbelievable even in the best of circumstances, but managing to continue to live even though he is completely covered in 3rd degree burns is stretching it a bit. Boyle also choses to shoot Pinbacker in trippy, unfocused manner which is distracting to the point of taking the viewer out of the story. Supposedly the reason for this is to provide a sense of unreality to a film that, up until Pinbacker's reveal, is filmed as realistically as such a thing can be filmed. The last 20 minutes or so leave the viewer with a "huh?" feeling and completely ruin what was a really good film.
The film is well shot, well acted, and well executed, but the story falls flat in the end. The effects, unlike some of the stuff in I Am Legend, were really great. Sadly, Boyle has stated that he will not visit the Sci-Fi genre again. I find this sad because there is some really good stuff in this try it just all didn't come together. I think he has the look and feel of good Sci-Fi down and his style in this film is very reminiscent of Ridley Scott's Alien. The production process, however, seems to have been a little too difficult for Boyle and he has sworn off Sci-Fi. Overall though I think it is a good film, but it misses out on being great.
A fun week of Sci-Fi. Next week I have some drama/history with
Zodiac and a film I don't have a lot of hope for,
The Contract.
The Out Campaign